The Turpin family members were the ultimate recyclers. Few names were used only once, but rather they keep coming back over and over, used sometimes in multiples. James is one of those names. The Turpins loved their Jameses. If you mix that with unreliable dates in documents, it’s the perfect recipe for a genealogist’s headache.
Early Setters of Tidewater Virginia, Volume 3 compiled by Elise Greenup Jourdan shows that Michael and Edith Turpin had sons named Obediah, John, and James. And we have Turpins in Owen County, Indiana named Obediah, John, and James who hailed from Virginia. That would appear to be a good fit. But the Indiana James does not usually match the Virginia James profile. He is on the edges of the age range for being a brother of Obediah and John and a son of Edith.
Obediah was probably born about 1761. John was born about 1770. James was born 1792 or 1798 or 1806 or 1820 depending on which record you are reading. Here is the James information formatted into a timeline.
Does he look like a brother to Obediah and John or a son of John? I am tempted to split this timeline. The events before 1820 are the James who is Michael’s son. The events starting in 1820 could be a son of John who is Michael’s son. I’ve found no direct evidence to support this idea but this timeline sort of points that way. Thoughts?